Clear Channel Limits Live CDs
I'm not quite sure what Clear Channel is thinking. Now, I could understand it if CC has a contract with the performers concerning the rights to broadcast the performance over the air. At work we always have to get a signed release form for concerts. Sometimes we can't because the group is under contract with some big-wig corporation. However, CC is saying, 'Hey , we have this patent, so we're the only ones who can do this!' not, 'Hey! we have exclusive rights to broadcast this performance, not you!'
This is more akin to McDonalds saying, 'Hey, we have the fast food chain patent, so none of you other fast food restaurants can be in business!' They're also extending that claim to cover every concert everywhere, even if CC isn't in the area. At least, that's how I read the article. Absolutely ridiculous.
Applying this to my work (since the Herndon Festival IS coming up), not only would we need permission to tape the concert, we would also need permission to sell copies of the performance. Of course, we also have no way to immediately mass-produce concert tapes. And we wouldn't dream of interfering with anybody else taping the concert. (heck, we'd probably ask them to help us!) It must be awful for bands who have no say in who can copy their performances. Slave labor, practically.
Of course, we're not in it for the money. Besides, live concerts are generally never 'perfect.' Singers forget words, equipment breaks, it starts to rain, the audience gets a little too out of hand, the guy sitting next to you talks the entire time, which the mic picks up . . . stuff happens. We've had concerts (particularly Great Big Sea) that wanted to see the performance we taped before they would allow us to re-air the concert. We duly sent them a copy. I'm sure they laughed their heads off before they said no. I still have the original. *coughs and gets back on topic*
If Clear Channel is going to try to control who copies performances, they should at least provide the right reason. Patents are not broadcast rights.